Croton Reservoir Tavern (W 40th St/6th Ave)

American • Comfort Food
Opens at 3:00 PM on Saturday
Next
Next

Shareables

Artichoke Dip

$18.00

Bang Bang Cauliflower

$16.00
Bang Bang Cauliflower

Cast Iron Shrimp

$23.00

Crispy Brussels

$18.00

CALAMARI

$22.00

Hummus

$16.00

Mega Pretzel

$16.00

Margherita Flatbread

$17.00

Return Of The Mac

$15.00

Roasted Garlic Flatbread

$18.00

Short Rib Flatbread

$20.00

Skillet Nachos

$18.00

Wings 12pc

$26.00

Wings 6pc

$14.00

Soup of the Day

$12.00

Tomato Bisque

$12.00

Appetizer Special

$17.00

Salads

All Hail Caesar!

$16.00

The Cobb

$21.00

Green Goddess

$18.00

Mediterranean Bowl

$19.00

Tuna Poke Bowl

$30.00

Handhelds

Crunch Croton

$22.00

Grilled Cheese & Tomato Bisque

$22.00

Croton Burger

$23.00

Tavern Burger

$21.00

Veggie Burger

$20.00

Braised Brisket

$23.00

Beer belly pulled pork

$20.00

Chicken Wrap

$20.00

Roast Beef Special

$22.00

Tacos

Brisket Tacos

$18.00

Chicken Tacos

$16.00

Pork Carnitas Tacos

$16.00

Tavern Favorites

Cacio Pepe

$29.00

Crispy Skin Salmon

$34.00

Roast Chicken

$31.00

Return of The Mac

$18.00

Steak Frites

$35.00

Ribeye

$46.00

Sides

Small Fries

$4.00

Small Sweet Fries

$4.00

Basket Fries

$11.00

Basket Sweet Fries

$12.00

Side Bread

$4.00

Carrots N Celery

$4.00

Side Chicken

$9.00

Side Pita

$3.00

Side salmon

$14.00

Side Salad

$7.00

Side Shrimp

$12.00

Side of tortilla chips

$5.00

Sautéed Broccolini

$10.00

Side Mashed Potatoes

$10.00

Side stuffing

$10.00

Extra Gravy

$3.00

Side Cajun Chips

$4.00

Basket Cajun Chips

$10.00

Desserts

Chocolate Gelato

$5.00

Assorted Cookie Plate

$12.00

Caramel Apple Cheesecake

$12.00

Chocolate Fudge Cake

$12.00

Brownie Sundae

$14.00

Vanilla Ice Cream

$4.00

Kids

Kids Chicken Tenders Fries

$14.00

Kids Pasta

$14.00

Kid Margarita Flatbread

$17.00

Kids Sliders w/Fries

$14.00

Kids Wings w/Fries

$15.00

Sliders

Cheese burger sliders

$16.00

Pulled pork sliders

$16.00

Veggie Sliders

$16.00

Glassware

CRT Wine Glass

logo Wine Glass
$15.00

CRT Beer Glass

logo Beer Glass
$13.00

$50 Pre-fixe menu

Pre-Theater Menu

$50.00

Shareables

Artichoke Dip

$19.50

Bang Bang Cauliflower

$17.50
Bang Bang Cauliflower

Cast Iron Shrimp

$24.50

Crispy Brussels

$19.50

CALAMARI

$23.50

Hummus

$17.50

Mega Pretzel

$17.50

Margherita Flatbread

$18.50

Return Of The Mac

$16.50

Roasted Garlic Flatbread

$19.50

Short Rib Flatbread

$21.50

Skillet Nachos

$19.50

Wings 12pc

$27.50

Wings 6pc

$15.50

Soup of the Day

$13.50

Tomato Bisque

$13.50

Appetizer Special

$18.50

Salads

All Hail Caesar!

$17.50

The Cobb

$22.50

Green Goddess

$19.50

Mediterranean Bowl

$20.50

Tuna Poke Bowl

$31.50

Handhelds

Crunch Croton

$23.50

Grilled Cheese & Tomato Bisque

$23.50

Croton Burger

$24.50

Tavern Burger

$22.50

Veggie Burger

$21.50

Braised Brisket

$24.50

Beer belly pulled pork

$21.50

Chicken Wrap

$21.50

Tacos

Brisket Tacos

$19.50

Chicken Tacos

$17.50

Pork Carnitas Tacos

$17.50

Tavern Favorites

Cacio Pepe

$30.50

Crispy Skin Salmon

$35.50

Roast Chicken

$32.50

Return of The Mac

$19.50

Steak Frites

$36.50

Ribeye

$47.50

Braised Lamb Shank

$36.50

Fish & Chips

$25.50

Sides

Small Fries

$5.50

Small Sweet Fries

$5.50

Basket Fries

$12.50

Basket Sweet Fries

$13.50

Side Bread

$5.50

Carrots N Celery

$5.50

Side Chicken

$10.50

Side Pita

$4.50

Side salmon

$15.50

Side Salad

$8.50

Side Shrimp

$13.50

Side of tortilla chips

$6.50

Sautéed Broccolini

$11.50

Side Mashed Potatoes

$11.50

Side stuffing

$11.50

Extra Gravy

$4.50

Desserts

Chocolate Gelato

$6.50

Assorted Cookie Plate

$13.50

Caramel Apple Cheesecake

$12.00

Chocolate Fudge Cake

$12.00

Brownie Sundae

$15.50

Vanilla Ice Cream

$5.50

Kids

Kids Chicken Tenders Fries

$15.50

Kids Pasta

$15.50

Kid Margarita Flatbread

$18.50

Kids Sliders w/Fries

$15.50

Kids Wings w/Fries

$16.50

Sliders

Cheese burger sliders

$17.50

Pulled pork sliders

$17.50

Veggie Sliders

$17.50
‌