New Yorker Deli (1140 Bay St)

Sandwiches • American
Opens at 9:00 AM on Saturday
Next
Next

Box Specials

  • Cup of Soup & Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $18.95
    Cup of Soup & Sandwich

  • Matzo Ball & Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $19.25

  • Cup of Soup & Garden Salad

    Made fresh.
    $18.95

  • Cup of Soup & Caesar Salad

    Made fresh.
    $18.95

  • Cup of Soup & Greek Salad

    Made fresh.
    $18.95

  • Cup of Soup & Spinach Salad

    Made fresh.
    $18.95

  • Beef Knish & Deli Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $19.95

  • Deli Sandwich & Salad

    Made fresh.
    $18.95

Combo Sandwiches

  • Corned Beef Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $18.95
    Corned Beef Combo Sandwich

  • Smoked Meat Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $18.95
    Smoked Meat Combo Sandwich

  • Pastrami Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $18.95
    Pastrami Combo Sandwich

  • Tuna Melt Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95
    Tuna Melt Combo Sandwich

  • Corned Beef & Swiss Cheese Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95

  • Corned Beef & Smoked Turkey Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95
    Corned Beef & Smoked Turkey Combo Sandwich

  • Corned Beef, Coleslaw & Sweet Red Pepper Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles on an onion bun.
    $20.95

  • Beef Dip with Onions & Peppers Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, dill pickles & sweet red peppers.
    $20.95
    Beef Dip with Onions & Peppers Combo Sandwich

  • Reuben Combo Sandwich

    Classic, smoked turkey, roast beef or corned beef. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95
    Reuben Combo Sandwich

  • Black Forest Ham with Grilled Vegetables & Cheddar Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, dill pickles & cheddar cheese.
    $19.95

  • Grilled Chicken with Grilled Vegetables & Cheddar Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95
    Grilled Chicken with Grilled Vegetables & Cheddar Combo Sandwich

  • Grilled Vegetables & Cheddar Cheese Combo Sandwich

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95

  • Carnegie Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $22.95

  • Club House Combo Sandwich

    Served with your choice of protein, side, coleslaw & dill pickles.
    $19.95
    Club House Combo Sandwich

All Day Breakfast

  • 3 Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $14.99

  • Bacon & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95
    Bacon & Eggs

  • Sausage & Eggs

    Served with homefries or Latkes your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Ham & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Peameal Bacon & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Corned Beef Hash & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Steak & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $20.95

  • Corned Beef & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $20.95

  • Salami & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Lox, Onions & Eggs

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $19.25

  • Eggs Benedict

    Served with your choice of side
    $19.25
    Eggs Benedict

  • Eggs Benedict with Smoked Salmon

    Served with your choice of side
    $20.95

  • Eggs Benedict with Roast Beef

    Served with your choice of side
    $20.95

  • Eggs Benedict with Corned Beef

    Served with your choice of side
    $20.95

  • Florentine

    Served with home fries
    $19.25

  • Western Sandwich

    Served with with home fries.
    $14.95
    Western Sandwich

  • New Yorker Sandwich

    Scrambled eggs, melted cheddar & peameal.
    $17.95
    New Yorker Sandwich

  • Fried Egg Sandwich

    Served with home fries.
    $12.50
    Fried Egg Sandwich

  • Texas Breakfast

    3 eggs, bacon, sausage, peameal & beans. Served with home your choice of side.
    $19.95
    Texas Breakfast

  • 1/2 French Toast

    2 slices of challah French toast, served with syrup
    $9.95
    1/2 French Toast

  • Cream Cheese Bagel

    Made fresh.
    $8.95

  • Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel

    Made fresh.
    $14.95
    Lox & Cream Cheese Bagel

  • Fresh Fruit Cup

    Made fresh.
    $8.95
    Fresh Fruit Cup

  • Granola Fruit & Yogurt

    Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Cheese Omelette

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $16.95

  • Veggie & Cheese Omelette

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95
    Veggie & Cheese Omelette

  • Western Omelette

    Served with your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Greek Omelette

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $16.95

  • Corned Beef Western Omelette

    Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • Mish Mash Omelette

    Wieners, fried onions & cheese. Served with home your choice of side & toast.
    $17.95

  • French Toast

    4 pieces of challah French toast, served with syrup
    $13.95
    French Toast

Burgers

  • Burger

    Served with fries. 1/2 lb.
    $16.50
    Burger

  • Brisket Burger

    Served with caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, dills & horseradish mayo with fries. 1/2 lb.
    $17.50

Wraps

  • Roast Brisket of Beef Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Turkey Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Chicken Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Corned Beef Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Pastrami Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Smoked Meat Wrap

    Includes garden salad mix (pepper, cucumber, tomato, mixed lettuce), coleslaw, mustard or mayo. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Club House Wrap

    Garden salad mix, grilled chicken, bacon & mayo. Made fresh.
    $14.95

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Romaine, Croutons, caesar salad dressing, chicken, and parmesan cheese
    $13.95
    Chicken Caesar Wrap

  • BLT Wrap

    Served with mixed vegetables & bacon. Vegetable mix includes lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers & celery.
    $13.95

  • Greek Chicken Wrap

    Garden salad mix, grilled chicken, feta cheese, black olives & our house vinaigrette. Made fresh.
    $13.95
    Greek Chicken Wrap

  • Mediterranean Wrap

    Garden salad mix, grilled chicken & hummus.
    $13.95

  • Lox & Cream Cheese Wrap

    Garden salad mix, cream cheese, and smoked salmon. Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Roast Beef Reuben Wrap

    Garden salad mix, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese & Russian dressing. Made fresh.
    $14.95

  • Pastrami Reuben Wrap

    Garden salad mix, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese & Russian dressing. Made fresh.
    $14.95

  • Smoked Turkey Reuben Wrap

    Garden salad mix, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese & Russian dressing. Made fresh.
    $14.95

Mr. Twisters Bagel Platters

  • Chicken Salad Platter

    Made fresh.
    $16.95
    Chicken Salad Platter

  • Sockeye Salmon Platter

    Made fresh.
    $16.95
    Sockeye Salmon Platter

  • Albacore Tuna Platter

    Made fresh.
    $16.95
    Albacore Tuna Platter

  • Egg Salad Platter

    Made fresh.
    $15.95
    Egg Salad Platter

  • Chopped Liver Platter

    Made fresh.
    $16.95
    Chopped Liver Platter

  • Triple Scoop Platter

    Made fresh.
    $21.95
    Triple Scoop Platter

  • Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese Platter

    Served with cucumbers, onions & tomatoes.
    $21.95
    Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese Platter

Splendid Things

  • Deli Platter

    Choose 3 meats. Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $26.95
    Deli Platter

  • Filet of Sole & Chips

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $14.95

  • Hot Turkey Dinner

    Made fresh Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $22.95

  • Hot Beef Dinner

    Made fresh Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $22.95

  • Corned Beef & Cabbage

    Made fresh Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $22.95
    Corned Beef & Cabbage

  • Chicken Pot Pie

    Made fresh Served with your choice of side & coleslaw & dill pickle.
    $16.95

Sandwiches

  • Corned Beef Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95
    Corned Beef Sandwich

  • Pastrami Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95
    Pastrami Sandwich

  • Smoked Meat Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95
    Smoked Meat Sandwich

  • Roast Brisket of Beef Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Salami Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Smoked Turkey Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Fresh Roast Turkey Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Chopped Liver Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Ham & Cheese Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95
    Chicken Salad Sandwich

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95
    Tuna Salad Sandwich

  • Sockeye Salmon Salad Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Egg Salad Sandwich

    Made fresh.
    $10.95
    Egg Salad Sandwich

  • Hot Meatloaf Sandwich & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $14.95

  • Grilled Cheese & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $11.75
    Grilled Cheese & Fries

  • Grilled Cheese & Bacon

    Made fresh.
    $13.95
    Grilled Cheese & Bacon

  • BLT Sandwich & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $13.95
    BLT Sandwich & Fries

  • Hot Dog & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $11.75
    Hot Dog & Fries

  • Chicken Fingers & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $13.95

  • Corned Beef Hash Sandwich & Fries

    Made fresh.
    $11.95

  • Wieners & Beans

    Made fresh. Served with fries.
    $15.95

Appetizers

  • Chopped Liver with Bagel Chips & Fried Onions

    Made fresh.
    $12.95
    Chopped Liver with Bagel Chips & Fried Onions

  • Kishka

    Made fresh.
    $9.95
    Kishka

  • Beef Knish

    Made fresh.
    $9.95
    Beef Knish

  • Potato Latkes

    Made fresh.
    $9.95
    Potato Latkes

  • Poutine

    Made fresh.
    $9.95

Salad Bowls

  • Garden Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $14.95
    Garden Salad

  • Spinach Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $16.95

  • Caesar Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $16.95

  • Greek Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $16.95
    Greek Salad

  • Deli Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $21.95

  • Cobb Salad

    Made fresh. Served with your choice of bagel.
    $21.95

Soups

  • Chicken Noodle Soup

    Made fresh.
    $8.50
    Chicken Noodle Soup

  • Cabbage Borscht Soup

    Made fresh.
    $8.95
    Cabbage Borscht Soup

  • Soup of the Day

    Made fresh.
    $8.50

  • Matzo Ball Soup

    Made fresh.
    $9.95
    Matzo Ball Soup

  • Kreplach Soup

    Made fresh.
    $8.95

Sides

  • French Fries

    $6.95

  • Home Fries

    $6.95

  • Mashed Potato

    Made fresh.
    $6.95

  • Onion Rings

    Made fresh.
    $6.95

  • Grilled Veggies

    Made fresh.
    $6.95
    Grilled Veggies

  • Potato Salad

    Made fresh.
    $4.50

  • Coleslaw

    Made fresh.
    $4.50

  • Sweet Peppers

    Made fresh.
    $2.50

  • Hot Peppers

    Made fresh.
    $2.50

  • Dill Tomatoes

    Made fresh.
    $2.50

  • Gravy

    Made fresh.
    $2.50

  • Sour Cream

    Made fresh.
    $1.50

  • Cream Cheese

    Made fresh.
    $3.75

  • Bacon

    Made fresh.
    $6.95

  • Sausage

    Made fresh.
    $6.95

  • Sweet Potato Fries

    $6.95

Beverages

  • Coffee

    House blend.
    $3.25

  • Tea

    $3.25

  • Milk

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $2.65

  • Juice

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $2.65

  • Pop

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $2.65

  • Milkshake

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $5.95

  • Iced Tea

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $3.50

  • Freshly Squeezed Juices

    Add a refreshment to your meal.
    $4.95

Desserts

  • Rugelach

    $2.25
    Rugelach

  • Cookie

    $2.25

Jarred Soups & Pickles

  • Chicken in a Pot

    Chicken and Matzo Balls
    $15.00
    Chicken in a Pot

  • Matzo Ball

    $13.00
    Matzo Ball

  • Lentil

    $13.00

  • Cabbage Borscht

    $15.00
    Cabbage Borscht

  • Beef Barley

    $13.00

  • Split Pea

    $13.00

  • Putter's Dill Pickles

    $7.50

  • Putter's Dill Tomatoes

    $8.50

  • Putter's Banana Peppers

    $7.50

  • Putter's Sweet Pimentos

    $7.50

  • Putter's Cherry Peppers

    Spicy
    $7.50

Chips

  • Miss Vickies Original

    $2.50

  • Miss Vickies Salt & Vinegar

    $2.50

By The Pound

  • Smoked Meat

    $27.95

  • Corned Beef

    $27.95

  • Roast Brisket of Beef

    $27.95

  • Coleslaw

    $9.00

  • Pastrami

    $27.95

  • Smoked Turkey

    $26.95

  • Fresh Roasted Turkey

    $27.95

  • Chopped Liver

    $19.95

  • Tuna Salad

    $19.95

  • Potato Salad

    $9.00

  • Fresh Roasted Turkey

    $27.95
‌