Potbelly Sandwich Shop (W 45th/5th)

Sandwiches
Opens at 11:00 AM on Thursday
Next
Next

Most Popular

  • Turkey Breast Sandwich (original)

    Hand-sliced turkey breast. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomato & mayo on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Turkey Breast Sandwich (original)

  • A Wreck Sandwich (original)

    Our signature sandwich! Salami, Angus roast beef, oven roasted turkey & hickory smoked ham. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $9.69
    A Wreck Sandwich (original)

  • Italian Sandwich (original)

    Featuring our four authentic Italian meats: capicola, mortadella, pepperoni & salami. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $9.69
    Italian Sandwich (original)

  • Farmhouse Salad (with chicken)

    All-natural grilled chicken, hard-boiled egg, bacon, blue cheese, cucumber, tomatoes & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Farmhouse Salad (with chicken)

  • Apple Walnut Salad (with chicken)

    All-natural grilled chicken, grapes, apples, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, blue cheese & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Apple Walnut Salad (with chicken)

  • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

    A Potbelly favorite! Baked fresh daily.
    $2.19
    Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

Pick Your Pair

  • Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Cup Soup

    Choose a skinny sandwich plus a cup of soup or chili.
    $10.89
    Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Cup Soup

  • Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Cup Mac

    Choose a half portion of your favorite sandwich plus a cup of mac & cheese.
    $10.89
    Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Cup Mac

  • Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Half Salad

    Choose a half portion of your favorite sandwich & a salad.
    $13.19
    Pick Your Pair Skinny Sandwich & Half Salad

  • Pick Your Pair Half Salad & Cup Soup

    Choose a half portion of your favorite salad plus a cup of soup or chili.
    $11.19
    Pick Your Pair Half Salad & Cup Soup

  • Pick Your Pair Salad & Mac

    Choose a half portion of your favorite salad plus a cup of mac & cheese.
    $11.19

Toasty Sandwiches (Skinny)

  • A Wreck Sandwich (Skinny)

    Our signature sandwich! Salami, Angus roast beef, oven roasted turkey & hickory smoked ham. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $7.49
    A Wreck Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Turkey Breast Sandwich (Skinny)

    Hand-sliced turkey breast. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomato & mayo on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Turkey Breast Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Smoked Ham Sandwich (Skinny)

    Hand-sliced hickory smoked ham. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Smoked Ham Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich (Skinny)

    100% Albacore tuna. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Tuna Salad Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Roast Beef Sandwich (Skinny)

    Thin-sliced Angus roast beef. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Roast Beef Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich (Skinny)

    Freshly made chicken salad with just the right amount of celery, mayo & pepper. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Chicken Salad Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Skinny)

    All-natural hand-sliced chicken breast. Recommended with melted cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $6.59
    Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Chicken Club Sandwich (Skinny)

    All-natural, grilled chicken with applewood smoked bacon. Recommended with cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $7.59
    Chicken Club Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Mama's Meatball Sandwich (Skinny)

    Homestyle beef & pork meatballs with just the right amount of marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese on multigrain.
    $7.59
    Mama's Meatball Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Italian Sandwich (Skinny)

    Featuring our four authentic Italian meats: capicola, mortadella, pepperoni & salami. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $7.49
    Italian Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Pizza Melt Sandwich (Skinny)

    Pizza the Potbelly Way! Pepperoni, meatballs, capicola & marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, mushrooms & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $7.39
    Pizza Melt Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (Skinny)

    All-natural chicken breast with zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $7.59
    Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (Skinny)

    Zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $7.09
    Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (Skinny)

  • Veggie Melt Sandwich (Skinny)

    Fresh sliced avocado, mushrooms, swiss, cheddar & provolone cheese
    $7.19
    Veggie Melt Sandwich (Skinny)

Toasty Sandwiches (Original)

  • A Wreck Sandwich (original)

    Our signature sandwich! Salami, Angus roast beef, oven roasted turkey & hickory smoked ham. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $9.69
    A Wreck Sandwich (original)

  • Turkey Breast Sandwich (original)

    Hand-sliced turkey breast. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomato & mayo on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Turkey Breast Sandwich (original)

  • Smoked Ham Sandwich (original)

    Hand-sliced hickory smoked ham. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Smoked Ham Sandwich (original)

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich (original)

    100% Albacore tuna. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Tuna Salad Sandwich (original)

  • Roast Beef Sandwich (original)

    Thin-sliced Angus roast beef. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Roast Beef Sandwich (original)

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich (original)

    Freshly made chicken salad with just the right amount of celery, mayo & pepper. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Chicken Salad Sandwich (original)

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich (original)

    All-natural hand-sliced chicken breast. Recommended with melted cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $8.89
    Grilled Chicken Sandwich (original)

  • Chicken Club Sandwich (original)

    All-natural, grilled chicken with applewood smoked bacon. Recommended with cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $10.59
    Chicken Club Sandwich (original)

  • Mama's Meatball Sandwich (original)

    Homestyle beef & pork meatballs with just the right amount of marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese on multigrain.
    $9.79
    Mama's Meatball Sandwich (original)

  • Italian Sandwich (original)

    Featuring our four authentic Italian meats: capicola, mortadella, pepperoni & salami. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $9.69
    Italian Sandwich (original)

  • Pizza Melt Sandwich (original)

    Pizza the Potbelly Way! Pepperoni, meatballs, capicola & marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, mushrooms & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $9.79
    Pizza Melt Sandwich (original)

  • Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (original)

    All-natural chicken breast with zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $10.09
    Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (original)

  • Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (original)

    Zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $9.29
    Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (original)

  • Veggie Melt Sandwich (original)

    Fresh sliced avocado, mushrooms, swiss, cheddar & provolone cheese
    $9.69
    Veggie Melt Sandwich (original)

Toasty Sandwiches (Big)

  • A Wreck Sandwich (Big)

    Our signature sandwich! Salami, Angus roast beef, oven roasted turkey & hickory smoked ham. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $13.29
    A Wreck Sandwich (Big)

  • Turkey Breast Sandwich (Big)

    Hand-sliced turkey breast. Recommended with melted Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomato & mayo on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Turkey Breast Sandwich (Big)

  • Smoked Ham Sandwich (Big)

    Hand-sliced hickory smoked ham. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Smoked Ham Sandwich (Big)

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich (Big)

    100% Albacore tuna. Recommended with Swiss cheese topped with fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Tuna Salad Sandwich (Big)

  • Roast Beef Sandwich (Big)

    Thin-sliced Angus roast beef. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Roast Beef Sandwich (Big)

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich (Big)

    Freshly made chicken salad with just the right amount of celery, mayo & pepper. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, fresh lettuce & tomatoes on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Chicken Salad Sandwich (Big)

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Big)

    All-natural hand-sliced chicken breast. Recommended with melted cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $12.19
    Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Big)

  • Chicken Club Sandwich (Big)

    All-natural, grilled chicken with applewood smoked bacon. Recommended with cheddar cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on multigrain.
    $14.19
    Chicken Club Sandwich (Big)

  • Mama's Meatball Sandwich (Big)

    Homestyle beef & pork meatballs with just the right amount of marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese on multigrain.
    $13.89
    Mama's Meatball Sandwich (Big)

  • Italian Sandwich (Big)

    Featuring our four authentic Italian meats: capicola, mortadella, pepperoni & salami. Recommended with provolone cheese topped with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $13.29
    Italian Sandwich (Big)

  • Pizza Melt Sandwich (Big)

    Pizza the Potbelly Way! Pepperoni, meatballs, capicola & marinara sauce. Recommended with melted provolone cheese, mushrooms & Italian seasoning on multigrain.
    $13.19
    Pizza Melt Sandwich (Big)

  • Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (Big)

    All-natural chicken breast with zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $13.69
    Mediterranean Chicken Sandwich (Big)

  • Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (Big)

    Zippy hummus. Recommended with feta cheese, artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers & roasted red peppers on multigrain.
    $12.69
    Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich (Big)

  • Veggie Melt Sandwich (Big)

    Fresh sliced avocado, mushrooms, swiss, cheddar & provolone cheese
    $13.19
    Veggie Melt Sandwich (Big)

Salads

  • Apple Walnut Salad (with chicken)

    All-natural grilled chicken, grapes, apples, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, blue cheese & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Apple Walnut Salad (with chicken)

  • Apple Walnut Salad (no chicken)

    Grapes, apples, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, blue cheese & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $8.59
    Apple Walnut Salad (no chicken)

  • Farmhouse Salad (with chicken)

    All-natural grilled chicken, hard-boiled egg, bacon, blue cheese, cucumber, tomatoes & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Farmhouse Salad (with chicken)

  • Farmhouse Salad (no chicken)

    Hard-boiled egg, bacon, blue cheese, cucumber, tomatoes & red onions, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $8.59
    Farmhouse Salad (no chicken)

  • Powerhouse Salad (with chicken)

    All-natural grilled chicken breast, avocado, hummus, egg, cucumber & tomatoes on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Powerhouse Salad (with chicken)

  • Powerhouse Salad (no chicken)

    Avocado, hummus, egg, cucumber & tomatoes on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $8.59
    Powerhouse Salad (no chicken)

  • Chicken Salad Salad

    Chicken salad, provolone cheese, dried cranberries, cucumber & tomatoes, served on a bed of romaine & field greens blend.
    $9.59
    Chicken Salad Salad

Mac & Soups

  • Broccoli Cheddar Soup (cup)

    Creamy cheese soup with tender pieces of broccoli & carrots.
    $4.49
    Broccoli Cheddar Soup (cup)

  • Broccoli Cheddar Soup (bowl)

    Creamy cheese soup with tender pieces of broccoli & carrots.
    $6.29
    Broccoli Cheddar Soup (bowl)

  • Garden Vegetable Soup (cup)

    Beans, carrots, celery, corn, mushrooms, onions, peppers, potatoes & zucchini in a light tomato broth.
    $4.49
    Garden Vegetable Soup (cup)

  • Garden Vegetable Soup (bowl)

    Beans, carrots, celery, corn, mushrooms, onions, peppers, potatoes & zucchini in a light tomato broth.
    $6.29
    Garden Vegetable Soup (bowl)

  • Loaded Baked Potato Soup (cup)

    Hearty potato soup with bacon, cheddar cheese & green onions.
    $4.49
    Loaded Baked Potato Soup (cup)

  • Loaded Baked Potato Soup (bowl)

    Hearty potato soup with bacon, cheddar cheese & green onions.
    $6.29
    Loaded Baked Potato Soup (bowl)

  • Chicken Pot Pie Soup (cup)

    $4.49
    Chicken Pot Pie Soup (cup)

  • Chicken Pot Pie Soup (bowl)

    $6.29
    Chicken Pot Pie Soup (bowl)

  • Chili (cup)

    Hearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers & onions.
    $4.49
    Chili (cup)

  • Chili (bowl)

    Hearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers & onions.
    $6.29
    Chili (bowl)

  • Mac & Cheese (cup)

    Creamy, three-cheese mac & cheese
    $4.49
    Mac & Cheese (cup)

  • Mac & Cheese (bowl)

    Creamy, three-cheese mac & cheese
    $6.29
    Mac & Cheese (bowl)

Sides & Chips

  • Whole Pickle

    $1.29

  • Zapp's Regular

    $1.79
    Zapp's Regular

  • Zapp's BBQ

    $1.79
    Zapp's BBQ

  • Zapp's Voodoo Heat

    $1.79
    Zapp's Voodoo Heat

  • Zapp's Jalapeno

    $1.79
    Zapp's Jalapeno

  • Zapp's Salt & Vinegar

    $1.79
    Zapp's Salt & Vinegar

  • Baked Lays

    $1.79
    Baked Lays

  • Dorito's Cool Ranch

    $0.00
    Dorito's Cool Ranch

  • Harvest Cheddar Sun Chips

    $1.79
    Harvest Cheddar Sun Chips

Desserts & Shakes

  • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

    A Potbelly favorite! Baked fresh daily.
    $2.19
    Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

  • Sugar Cookie

    Baked fresh daily.
    $2.19
    Sugar Cookie

  • Chocolate Brownie Cookie

    Baked fresh daily.
    $2.19
    Chocolate Brownie Cookie

  • Dream Bar

    Rich, chocolatey oatmeal bar with sweet caramel.
    $2.29
    Dream Bar

  • Bag of Mini Cookies

    Dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies.
    $4.79
    Bag of Mini Cookies

  • Oreo Cookie Shake

    Made with hand-scooped ice cream. OREO is a trademark of Mondelēz International group, used under license.
    $4.79
    Oreo Cookie Shake

  • Chocolate Shake

    Made with hand-scooped ice cream.
    $4.79
    Chocolate Shake

  • Strawberry Shake

    Made with hand-scooped ice cream.
    $4.79
    Strawberry Shake

  • Vanilla Shake

    Made with hand-scooped ice cream.
    $4.79
    Vanilla Shake

Drinks

  • Bottled Soda (20oz)

    Choose from a variety of flavors.
    $2.99

  • Bottled Water

    25 oz.
    $2.69
    Bottled Water

  • Bottled Water

    16 oz.
    $2.19
    Bottled Water

  • Powerade Mountain Berry Blast

    20 oz.
    $2.99
    Powerade Mountain Berry Blast

  • Arizona Tea

    20 oz. bottle.
    $2.99
    Arizona Tea

  • Diet Snapple 1/2 & 1/2

    16 oz. bottle.
    $2.99
    Diet Snapple 1/2 & 1/2

  • IBC Soda

    12 oz. bottle.
    $2.99
    IBC Soda

  • San Pellegrino

    16.9 oz. bottle.
    $2.99
    San Pellegrino

  • Canned San Pellegrino Blood Orange

    11.5 oz. can.
    $2.99
    Canned San Pellegrino Blood Orange

  • Honest Organic Honey Green Tea

    Bottle 16.9oz
    $2.99
    Honest Organic Honey Green Tea
‌